
A Great Product Isn't Enough: Why Marketing Determines Who Wins
October 22, 2026 · Josué Sosa Rodríguez
Is your product great but not selling? Discover why Coca-Cola won even when Pepsi tasted better, and learn seven marketing strategies to help your business stand out.
Many entrepreneurs believe quality sells itself. They bake the best bread in the neighborhood, build flawless furniture, or provide outstanding service, yet they watch the competitor across the street attract more customers with an inferior product. The difference is rarely the product itself. It's how the product is presented, where it's showcased, and how customers feel when they buy it.
There's no better example of this than the cola wars between Coca-Cola and Pepsi.
The Classic Case: The Pepsi Challenge
In 1975, Pepsi launched the Pepsi Challenge, a blind taste test in which people tried two unbranded cups of cola and chose their favorite. The ads began in Texas and eventually spread across the United States, with the cups labeled with letters to conceal which drink was which (Mental Floss).
According to Pepsi's campaign, more people preferred its taste. Pepsi even claimed that half of those who said they preferred Coca-Cola ended up choosing Pepsi in the blind test (Historical Society of Pottawattamie County).
There's an important caveat: the Pepsi Challenge was an advertising campaign, not a scientific study (Wikipedia: Cola Wars). In his book Blink, Malcolm Gladwell explained that a sweeter drink tends to win when people take a single sip, even though their preferences may differ when drinking an entire can (Media Shower).
Still, the lesson holds: although Pepsi came out ahead in blind taste tests, Coca-Cola continued to outsell it (Cal Poly). If taste alone determined purchasing decisions, the story would have turned out differently.
What Science Says: Branding Changes How We Feel
In 2004, a team led by neuroscientist Read Montague recreated the Pepsi Challenge inside a brain scanner and found that branding could outweigh taste.
The study, published in the journal Neuron, started with an intriguing observation: Coca-Cola and Pepsi have very similar chemical compositions, yet people have strong preferences for one or the other. Researchers conducted two tests: one blind and another in which participants were told which brand they were drinking.
| Test Type | What Happened |
|---|---|
| Blind taste test | Preferences were split; in several replications, Pepsi came out slightly ahead. |
| With brands visible | Three out of four said they preferred Coca-Cola, and brain regions associated with memory and identity were activated. |
According to The New York Times, Montague concluded that people weren't choosing just a drink, but the drink combined with everything the brand evoked in their minds. Knowing that they were drinking Coca-Cola activated the hippocampus, a brain region associated with memory, as well as part of the prefrontal cortex.
Put simply, decades of advertising, memories, and emotions come along with every sip. The study has also faced methodological criticism and shouldn't be interpreted as evidence of a "buy button" in the brain. However, its central message remains clear: brand perception changes how people experience a product.
New Coke: When Coca-Cola Forgot What It Was Selling
In April 1985, Coca-Cola changed its formula to make it more like Pepsi. Just 79 days later, the company had to bring back the original formula.
The decision seemed logical on paper. According to the company, nearly 200,000 consumers had preferred the new formula in taste tests before its launch (6abc). But customers reacted furiously. Some stockpiled the original Coca-Cola, and protest groups emerged, including the "Society for the Preservation of the Real Thing" (ABC7).
On July 11, 1985, the original formula returned under the name Coca-Cola Classic. Years later, the company explained on its website that the tests hadn't measured the emotional bond people had with their Coca-Cola—a connection that no one, not even the company itself, should have tampered with (6abc).
The lesson for any business is twofold. First, customers don't just buy a product; they buy a story, a habit, and an identity. Second, that emotional connection is an asset just as valuable as the recipe itself.
It's Not Just Coca-Cola: Other Cases That Prove the Point
The same story plays out across very different industries: the best product loses, while the product with the better story wins.
The Betamax case, however, requires an important distinction: it didn't lose solely because of advertising. Sony also failed to listen to what customers needed. That's marketing, too: understanding the market before trying to reach it.
| Case | The product | What decided the outcome | Lesson for your business |
|---|---|---|---|
| Betamax vs. VHS | Sony’s Betamax had better picture quality and more vivid colors | VHS recorded two hours versus one, was cheaper, and had more movies available to rent | Sell what the customer values, not what you think is “better” |
| Dollar Shave Club | Cheap razor blades by subscription, an ordinary product | A humorous video that cost about $4,500 sold out its inventory within hours; in 2016 Unilever bought the company for about $1 billion | A clear personality and an honest message can be worth more than a big budget |
| Liquid Death | Water, in a can | A rebellious, funny brand presented as if it were beer; in March 2024 it was valued at $1.4 billion | Even the most basic product can stand out through identity and attitude |
Why a Great Product Doesn't Sell: The Most Common Mistakes
More often than not, the problem isn't quality. It's that customers don't see it, understand it, or remember it.
Believing quality speaks for itself. Customers don't try your product blindfolded. They choose it based on what they see, hear, and feel before making a purchase.
Talking about features instead of benefits. "Organic stone-ground flour" doesn't say much to most customers. "Bread that stays soft for three days" solves a problem.
Not knowing who you're selling to. Trying to appeal to everyone leads to generic messages that connect with no one.
A neglected brand image. An improvised logo, dark photos, and abandoned social media accounts make customers assume the product is just as neglected.
Being invisible. If you're not where your customers look—Google Maps, Instagram, WhatsApp, or the local marketplace—you might as well not exist to them.
Competing on price alone. Cutting prices without building a brand attracts customers who will leave as soon as someone offers a cheaper alternative.
Failing to tell a story. Coca-Cola doesn't sell sugar water; it sells moments, tradition, and happiness. Your business has a story, too.
Seven Strategies to Help Your Great Product Sell
You don't need Coca-Cola's budget. You need clarity, consistency, and a connection with your customers.
1. Define your ideal customer. Write down who they are, what concerns them, and where they spend their time. Build your entire message around that understanding.
2. Identify what makes you different and express it in one sentence. Liquid Death doesn't describe itself as just another brand of pure water; it says something no one else does. What makes your business unique?
3. Tell your story. Explain who you are, why you started, and how you make what you sell. Stories stick in people's minds; price lists don't.
4. Take care of your brand image. A simple but professional logo, well-lit photos, and consistent packaging increase perceived value.
5. Be visible where your customers are. Complete your Google Business Profile, keep your social media active with regular posts, and offer an easy way to get in touch, such as WhatsApp.
6. Use social proof. Reviews, testimonials, and photos of real customers do what Pepsi's Challenge aimed to do: show people that others have already chosen you.
7. Create memorable experiences and emotional connections. Excellent service, a thoughtful touch in your packaging, or a signature tradition can turn customers into fans, just like those who defended the original Coca-Cola in 1985.
Start with just one of these actions this week and measure what changes before moving on to the next.
Conclusion: The Product Opens the Door; Marketing Gets People Through It
Pepsi may have won on taste, but Coca-Cola won in people's minds and hearts.
A great product is the foundation. Without one, marketing can't sustain a business for long. But a great product without marketing is a well-kept secret. Successful businesses combine both: they create something valuable and know how to communicate its value.
If you feel your business deserves more customers than it currently has, the problem might not be what you're selling, but how you're presenting it. Review your brand image, your message, and your online presence this week.
And tell us in the comments: What product do you think is better than its competition but still sells less?
Sources
- Cola wars — Wikipedia
- 11 Classic Blind Taste Test Commercials — Mental Floss
- McClure et al. (2004), Neuron 44(2): 379-387
- There's a Sucker Born in Every Medial Prefrontal Cortex — New York Times, 2004 (copia)
- Beverage Backlash: History of New Coke — 6abc
- The Real Reason Betamax Lost The Format Wars — SlashGear
- Unilever to Buy Dollar Shave Club — NBC News
- Liquid Death — Wikipedia